Man who said homosexuality and abortion are evil loses discrimination case

A Dubliner who listed a key achievement as standing up for his religious beliefs which include that “homosexuality is an intrinsic disorder inclined towards evil” has lost a discrimination case.

The Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) threw out the discrimination case taken by Mark Savage against employment advisors, Seetec Employment And Skills Ireland - writes irishtimes.com.

WRC Adjudication Officer, Ian Barrett found that Mr Savage has not proved primary facts of sufficient significance to raise the inference of discrimination.

Mr Savage’s CV was submitted for a vacancy in a healthcare firm and in the Key Achievements section, Mr Savage wrote: “Standing up for and defending my religious beliefs which include that abortion on demand is evil and homosexuality is an intrinsic disorder inclined towards evil”.

Mr Savage claimed that on reading the section, his employment advisor at Seetec Employment And Skills Ireland said “you can’t say that, employers are biased”, which is when Mr Savage alleged the discrimination occurred.

Mr Savage alleged that he was discriminated against under Section 21 of the Equal Status Act by being treated less favourably than other people on the ground of religion and by being treated unlawfully by being discriminated against in the provision of goods and services.

Seetec does not accept that the Employment Advisor used these words, and submitted that the advice given was constructive in nature, made without partiality or bias and was solely job related.

Seetec told the hearing that an employer advisor asked Mr Savage why he had included the line, telling him that as not all employers would share his views on abortion and homosexuality and this might influence their decision whether to invite him for interview.

Mr Savage advised that it is immaterial if the comment by his employment advisor was only intended to advise him that the wording was detrimental to his prospects of getting an interview.

He stated he is proud of his achievements and being told that he could not include them on his CV “caused him emotional upset and distress”.

At the hearing, Mr Savage contended that if an individual with an LGBT background listed as a key achievement on their CV that they had campaigned for a Yes vote in the marriage referendum, or someone with a disability stated that they had campaigned vigorously for improved services for wheelchair users, then in all probability, the employment advisor would not have cautioned such a person in the same way.

Mr Savage believes that notwithstanding the fact that the employment advisor had a valid concern that the wording on the CV would diminish his employment prospects, he would not say the same thing to a comparator and therefore he was discriminated against because of his religious beliefs and the advisor’s employer is vicariously liable.

An Operations Director for Seetec explained that it is their function to advise clients on the format and content of their CV, to enhance their prospects of obtaining interviews and employment.

He stated that at no stage did the Employment Advisor ask that Mr Savage to remove the text or wording but proffered his opinion that the content of the Key Achievements section would diminish his employment prospects.

Seetec told the hearing that their employees do not make judgements regarding the views or beliefs of any of its clients, but that they are respected.

However, they would be negligent in their duties if they did not provide professional opinion or advice to enhance their client’s prospects of gaining employment.

Seetec stated that they were unaware of Mr Savage’s religious beliefs and they were of no relevance to the service they provided; the employment advisor had acted impartially and was not biased in any way.

Seetec stated that the evidence shows that the wording used on the Mr Savage’s CV goes beyond an expression of his religious beliefs. Furthermore, they alleged that at a review meeting between Mr Savage and the employment advisor in December 2016, Mr Savage expressed his opinion that homosexuality is an intrinsic disorder inclined towards evil and gay people are an abomination of nature.

Seetec concluded by saying that Mr Savage is unable to make a prima facie case that discrimination took place and has not linked any of the points he raises to the alleged religious discrimination.

In his ruling Mr Barrett said the evidence does not support the contention that Mr Savage was treated differently or less favourably on the grounds of religion and as Mr Savage does not discharge the initial probative burden which he bears, his case cannot succeed.

Read also other Dublin news here.

irishtimes.com
IanBarrett MarkSavage Seetec Workplace_Relations_Commission
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
1 view in december
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Society
A man and woman were arrested following a stabbing incident that left Dublin city centre on lockdown on Sunday evening. The pair were taken to Pearse st station after another man in his early 20s was hospitalised with 'non-fatal injuries'. It is believed a fight spilled out onto the road with one witness telling Dublin Live that she thought the man was going to be "throw him into the river". She said: "They stopped the traffic while they were fighting that...
Society
The final report into the marine tragedy in which Doolin-based volunteer coastguard crew member Caitríona Lucas died in 2016 is critical of safety aspects of the operation. It concluded that the Delta Rigid Inflatable Boat that capsized was launched in conditions that were outside the operational limits of the vessel and that there were deficiencies with its communications and navigational equipment. Ms Lucas, a 41-year-old mother-of-two living in Liscanno...
Society
A software development company is to create 85 jobs in Galway over the next 12 months. MathWorks says the expansion will lead to the recruitment of candidates with sales, service, marketing or administrative skills. It hopes to hire 20 people immediately with the remaining 65 roles being filled in 2019. The company opened an office in Galway two years ago. It provides sales and services support throughout Europe, the Middle East and Asia, with staff operat...
Incidents
A woman was allegedly sexually assaulted by a taxi driver in North Dublin on Saturday night. The woman, believed to be in her 30s, had been picked up by a registered taxi from the Main Street in Malahide after socialising in the area and was heading in the Swords direction. It is believed after the taxi driver dropped off the other people in the car, the alleged victim was left alone with the driver for a stretch of road. The taxi driver then allegedly sex...
Society
A man was yesterday convicted of assaulting and injuring his neighbour by “continuously punching and head-butting him”. Peter Lambe, 50, was found guilty of assaulting 62-year-old Gerard Furlong after he pinned the grandad to the ground and left him bloodied and bruised. The victim, who said he is still in constant fear, suffered serious facial injuries during the frenzied attack on March 4, 2016, which came after ongoing disputes. Mr Furlong described how...
Society
The long-suffering father of Trevor Deely has told how he refuses to abandon his dream that his missing son will one day walk back through the front door of his family home. Heartbroken parents Michael and Ann Deely have endured yet another agonising year in which not one single lead has emerged into their youngest son’s baffling disappearance. But speaking on the eve of the 18th anniversary of the last sighting of the then-22-year-old, resolute Michael sa...
Society
The funny note left on the car, which will teach them. A motorist in Dublin was left with a hilarious note on their car after some "arseways parking". A Dublin Live reader sent us in a picture of the unique note perched on the window of the vehicle. The note says: "Many three year olds have trouble staying within the lines. "Maybe if you practice colouring this turtle, it will help with your parking." The reader said the driver was parked "arseways" outsid...
Society
A surge in Corporation Tax payments last month will go towards making Ireland's finances safer by the end of the year, the Minister for Finance has said. When asked whether the additional money could be spent on alleviating the housing crisis, Paschal Donohoe said he has made some of the funding available for the needs of today. However, he said that "the right thing to do" is to allow the "higher than expected tax collection to flow through into improving...
Society
The Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy Bill, which will allow for the introduction of abortion services, will proceed to the Seanad after passing all stages in the Dáil last night.  TDs voted in favour of the abortion legislation by 90 votes to 15, with 12 abstentions. The midnight vote in the Dáil came after hours of debate and more than 60 amendments.  Minister for Health Simon Harris described the passage of the legislation as a significant step for...