Nama planned email deletion policy one month before becoming subject to Freedom of Information

NAMA PLANNED FOR a change to its email policy to allow for old staff emails to be deleted one month before it became subject to Freedom of Information laws.

The policyallowsfor staff emails to be deleted one year after they leave the agency – but Nama claims this is only done after any valuable documents have been retained.

The policy came into effect in March 2015 – one month before Nama became subject to Freedom of Information requests . The Freedom of Information Act obliges government departments and public bodies to make the information they hold available to citizens and journalists - writes

In September 2011 the then Commissioner for Environmental Information Emily O’Reilly ruled that Nama was a “public authority” as outlined in regulations on environmental information.Requests for environmental information are governed under a system similar to Freedom of Information requests.

Nama appealed the ruling by O’Reilly but the High Court dismissed the appeal in February 2013 .

Just over two years later Nama became subject to FOI on 14 April 2015. One month before it became subject to FOI requests Nama planneda change to its email policy.

Records of a Nama board meeting – provided through Freedom of Information – show that the Nama Board held a meeting on 12 March 2015 where it was recommended that “email records of Nama officers be deleted one year after their departure from the agency”.

Approval was also sought to apply this proposal retrospectively to the email records of former Nama officers.

‘Managers can authorise the deletion’

Independents 4 Change TD Mick Wallace questioned the Minister for Finance and Public Expenditure about the appropriateness of the policy.

Paschal Donohoe admitted that Nama does delete staff emails after a year but stressed that not all emails are deleted.

“It is important to clarify that any suggestion that NAMA deletes all emails of staff members one year after departure is not correct.”

He said the first step Nama takes is to “ensure that all emails of business or long-term value are retained in the appropriate repositories”.

Donohoe added that business and long-term value records are saved but managers can authorise the deletion of transitory emails that have no business value.

Only when managers are assured that such records have been retained and stored can they authorise the deletion of ephemeral and transitory emails that have no business value.

He added that all key records held by Nama are retained and are available for business purposes and for the purposes of legal discovery.

‘Best practice’

He said officials in his department were told by Nama thatits email retention policy is in line with best practice among public and private organisations.

TheJournal.ieasked Nama for examples of such organisations but a spokesperson for Nama said it was “not adding to the Minister’s comments on this matter”.

Wallace said, “No other State agency has this policy.

The policy of deleting staff emails 12 months after they have left the agency is not in line with the approach of any similar organisation in the public sector.

Nama’s parent agency – the National Management Treasury Agency (NTMA) – does not have a set timeframe regarding the retention or deletion of emails.

Wallace questioned this, asking, “Why would Nama delete emails when the NTMA does not do so?”

TheJournal.iealso asked Nama if it knew of any other State agency that uses this policy, but it replied to all questions by saying that it was not adding to the Minister’s comments.

Wallace said:

Nama is erasing the history of what goes on within the organisation and ensuring that it is not open to any embarrassment as a result of FOI requests.

Data protection

Wallace also addressed Nama’s recent data protection case, saying: “Nama is a law unto itself and nobody is holding it to account.”

The Data Protection Commissioner Helen Dixon recently found that Nama was in breach of its obligations under data protection law regarding developers Michael and John O’Flynn.

The O’Flynns gave Nama more than 2,000 pages of documents when the agency took over the O’Flynn Construction Group’s bank debt in 2010.

Nama then sold the loans to Blackstone in May 2013 and in September 2014, the brothersasked Nama for all data it held on them.

It should have been supplied to them in 40 days but Nama gave limited amounts of information.

The Commissioner foundNama failed or refused to provide the O’Flynns with the type of personal data on them that the agency processed, the Irish Times reported.

Helen Dixon added that Nama failed to communicate to the O’Flynns the full extent of the personal data that it held and the source of that information.

Wallace said, “It is a shocking case.”

Nama has 21 days from the ruling in which to appeal to the Circuit Court.

Donohoe saidthe board of Nama is currently considering the ruling of the Data Protection Commissioner and it will respond to it.

Read more news of Dublin on our site.
Namaplanned Freedom
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
4 views in november
I recommend
No recommendations yet


Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Inner City Helping Homeless are asking for the public's help in filling a Luas with gifts this Christmas. Fill A Luas asks the public to donate a shoebox of gifts to the homeless at Connolly Luas Stop on Thursday, December 6. This is the fourth year of the charity event. This year, Fill A Luas will be a week-long event to give people more time to donate a shoebox over the holidays with the aim of collecting more than the record of 20,000 shoeboxes. The pub...
The sightings of UFOs over the coast by three sets of airline pilots has led to Ireland being seen as a hotbed of alien activity. It has emerged the crews who reported an unidentified object streaking through the skies over Co Kerry are not alone. Dublin Live has been inundated with reports of similar sightings around the country in recent weeks. The Irish Aviation Authority has begun an investigation into the appearance of the mysterious objects which wer...
Ombudsman Peter Tyndall has expressed his disappointment that the Health Service Executive has not fully implemented the recommendations made in his 2015 investigation into the healthcare system. The Ombudsman's 2015 report, Learning to Get Better, found that many people were afraid to complain about the treatment they receive in hospitals and that many hospitals were not learning important lessons from complaints they receive.  The HSE and Department of H...
A new programme aimed at helping immigrant teachers find work in Irish schools opens to applicants today. The course, at Dublin’s Marino Institute of Education, aims to provide immigrants who are qualified teachers, but not working as such, with the knowledge, skills, and confidence to enable them to find employment here. Recent research has found that while Ireland’s school student population is now highly diverse, teachers here continue to be overwhelmin...
EU and UK negotiators have agreed a text that deals with the Irish border, RTÉ News understands. The text was agreed at around 9pm last night and then transmitted to Downing Street. While two well-placed sources have confirmed that the text was "as stable as it can be", they say it would not be correct to say that the negotiations have "concluded". According to both sources, there will be one backstop to avoid a hard border on the island of Ireland. The ba...
The Cabinet will meet this morning to consider developments around the draft text of a Brexit withdrawal agreement. Yesterday, Taoiseach Leo Varadkar put his colleagues on standby for this morning's meeting, which is due to be held at 9.30am. Mr Varadkar and the Tánaiste will update their Government colleagues on what has happened over the last 24 hours. It follows a meeting last night between Mr Varadkar, Tánaiste Simon Coveney, Minister for Finance Pasch...
A number of events have taken place around the country and in Northern Ireland to mark the centenary of the ending of World War I. Locations where ceremonies have taken place include Belfast, Enniskillen, Cork, Limerick, Sligo, Kilkenny, Westmeath, Galway and Tipperary. In Cork city, Lord Mayor of Cork Cllr Mick Finn laid a wreath at the Cenotaph on the Grand Parade. He was joined by relatives of those who died in WWI and members of the Cork branch of the...
The two men who were arrested in Athy, Co Kildare yesterday in the investigation into the murder of David Boland have been released without charge today. A file will be prepared for the Director of Public Prosecutions as the investigation continues, said a garda spokesperson. David Boland, 34, was stabbed multiple times during an incident on Duke Street in Athy, in the early hours of Thursday 1 November. A total of four people have been arrested to date as...
Dublin City Council is set to spend €1.6 million on the removal of discarded chewing gum in public areas. The local authority is seeking tenders for a contract to remove gum from footpaths and pedestrianised zones throughout litter blackspots in its administrative area over the next three years. It expects to spend €1.6 million plus VAT on these services, according to tender documents. The huge cost of removing chewing gum from public areas comes despite r...